Breaking NTO 2.0 partially upheld by Bombay HC

  • Thread starter Thread starter Vadirocks
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies: Replies 709
  • Views Views: Views 94,621
Status
Not open for further replies.
Trai 1.0 case

Win
Channel price -19 and Ncf -130 tax extra etc....

Loss
Bouquet condition for restitution in discount..


Trai 2.0 case

Win
Channel price 12 and Ncf-130 tax extra etc...

Loss
restitution in discount they put two condition in bouquet making...

Both cases broadcasters win what they want. They not worried about mrp 12 rs . They worried about two condition . It leads remove unwanted channel from their bouquet.
Trai want restitution in discount for unwanted channel in bouquet. They loss two condition in bouquet.
Trai may go for appeal...
Trai 2.0 output
1. Ncf is 130 + tax
2. Ncf price depends upon mso and dth
3. Broadcaster may increase channel price which is Lower in trai 1.0 to adjust price what price they bouquet price in trai 1.0

Example
Trai 1.0
Ch1 - 19 ( wanted)
Ch2- 12 (wanted )
Ch3 - 1 ( unwanted)
Ch4 - 0.5 ( unwanted)
Total mrp - 32.5
Bouquet price -24

Trai 2.0
Ch1 - 12 ( wanted)
Ch2- 12 (wanted )
Ch3 - 5 ( unwanted)
Ch4 - 3 ( unwanted)
Total mrp - 32
Bouquet price -24

4. Most hd and SD price decrease in ala Cate ....
 
Last edited:
Firstly 18% GST is just brainless.
We have to pay 18% for every single channels then again pay 18% for all channels put together. Tax itself makes 1/3rd of the total amount
Broadcasters must pay tax. And consumers must pay 18% only for total amount.

Also why should we pay for FTA. They are meant to be free. Won't broadcaster pay for cable / DTH a carriage fee.
 
Firstly 18% GST is just brainless.
We have to pay 18% for every single channels then again pay 18% for all channels put together. Tax itself makes 1/3rd of the total amount
Broadcasters must pay tax. And consumers must pay 18% only for total amount.

Also why should we pay for FTA. They are meant to be free. Won't broadcaster pay for cable / DTH a carriage fee.
Agree with you, correct 18% Tax waste,
 
only profit I can see if you are choosing ala carte.
Mostly I hope sports channel viewers and HD viewers will be benefited. Still you will not get much benefit if you are selecting huge number of channels.
 
Firstly 18% GST is just brainless.
We have to pay 18% for every single channels then again pay 18% for all channels put together. Tax itself makes 1/3rd of the total amount
Broadcasters must pay tax. And consumers must pay 18% only for total amount.

Also why should we pay for FTA. They are meant to be free. Won't broadcaster pay for cable / DTH a carriage fee.
Who told you this nonsense?

We are paying 18% only. Not double that. Go and check properly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom