Breaking NTO 2.0 To Be Implemented From 1st February 2023

[dino29]

It is YOU who need to have a relook at it, as I have asked you multiple times to post the bouquet details from the Airtel Digital TV website, and you FAILED to do so. Since you failed to do so, I'm doing it for you from the Airtel Digital TV website below, Now you need to accept that you are wrong, as the discount percentage is NOT 33, but it is 35 (Without Tax).

Already answered this in above 2 posts

WRONG again. NTO 1.0 rules were NOT in place before the honorable Supreme Court Order was pronounced. The broadcasters approached the Madras high court way back in 2017, not only for the 15% discount cap cancellation, they wanted the entire NTO itself to be cancelled. After the Madras HC upheld the NTO 1.0 in March 2018, barring 15% discount capping rule, the broadcasters then went to Supreme Court and ONLY after the Supreme Court pronounced its judgement in 2019, FINALLY NTO 1.0 came into effect without any discount cap, and they published the NTO 1.0 compliant RIOs. You are TOTALLY WRONG with all your timelines. You are saying that the NTO is in place, even before Madras high court order and the broadcasters published RIOs to that effect. This is completely FALSE. Correct yourself thambi.

Buddy read again what i said. I said that that TRAI directed broadcasters to publish RIO complying with NTO Rules back in 2018 as same were to b implemented in 2019 and then broadcasters went to Madras High Court objecting to NTF regulations. I did not said NTO rules were already in effect before Madras High Court judgement, i said Broadcasters were required to publish RIO before that so that same can be implemented in 2019. Later. NTO implementation got deferred to March 2020.

The Supreme Court plea which i am referring to is not the 2019 one but recent one which was filed against the Bombay High Court order which gave go ahead to NTO 2.0 barring 2nd twin condition . Here is an article for the same, where broadcasters which mentions about broadcasters withdrawing this plea.

TV broadcasters withdraw petitions challenging Trai’s NTO 2.0

While allowing the withdrawal, the Supreme Court has kept the question of law of the broadcasters' challenge open, thereby, allowing the broadcasting industry the ability to re-agitate the legal challenge at a future date, if Trai fails to address their concerns

www.google.com

You are incorrect in all these statements as I stated above.

I am not wrong anna rather u r getting confused and not understanding all the points properly

 

[satyajeet]

This is a forum not a social media site like twitter where you would expect 140 characters. We actually get to learn something via these lengthy post. Also you can't ask for reactions. It's not allowed.

These lengthy posts are repetitive too. We dont learn more if we read same thing 10 times. You can't wake someone who pretends to be sleeping. I asked opinion via reactions which is easier then replying.

 

[dino29]

These lengthy posts are repetitive too. We dont learn more if we read same thing 10 times. You can't wake someone who pretends to be sleeping. I asked opinion via reactions which is easier then replying.

Please don't indulge in name calling or making derogatory comments. If u r willing to learn u would need to invest time, patience and energy to decode facts properly else u would remain confused and take the easy way out to say that i am wrong which does not serve any purpose.

All the information i have shared is based on lot of immense research and hours spent in trying to put all parts of information in right sequence so that logical/proper reasoning can b arrived at as to why and how these varying prices / bouquet discount of different broadcasters came into implementation

 

[Nikhil Shirvankar]

Already answered this in above 2 posts

The point is that what @Siva bro posted is a simple table showing clear calculations and proving that Bouquet discount on Airtel Digital TV for SVP is 35%

What I've posted are screen captures from Airtel Digital TV Manage My pack section, again showing that the Bouquet discount on Airtel Digital TV for SVP is 34.75%

While what you're are doing is posting theories and all article links.

A lot theories happened surrounding NTO, but the fact in practical still remains that NTO original (call it 1.0) is existent still and is existent still without any cap on Bouquet discount pricing on Airtel Digital TV as well and new one comes in FEB 2023 (it's still a theory until it comes live).

You haven't posted any simple table or any official calculations from DPO websites, you haven't posted a practical example, you have just posted and quoted theories, theories that everyone knows.

And why should we believe only in theories when we have actual practical examples stated.

 

[Siva]

Already answered this in above 2 posts

Where did you answer, I posted the discount percentage of 35% for the SVP bouquet from Airtel Digital TV. 35>33. Are you saying 35<33? What are you trying to say? Repeat it

Buddy read again what i said. I said that that TRAI directed broadcasters to publish RIO complying with NTO Rules back in 2018 as same were to b implemented in 2019 and then broadcasters went to Madras High Court objecting to NTF regulations. I did not said NTO rules were already in effect before Madras High Court judgement, i said Broadcasters were required to publish RIO before that so that same can be implemented in 2019. Later. NTO implementation got deferred to March 2020.

The Supreme Court plea which i am referring to is not the 2019 one but recent one which was filed against the Bombay High Court order which gave go ahead to NTO 2.0 barring 2nd twin condition . Here is an article for the same, where broadcasters which mentions about broadcasters withdrawing this plea.

BUDDY, You are saying that the broadcasters went to Madras High Court in 2018, which is again WRONG. They went in 2017, immediately after TRAI notified the NTO 1.0 in 2017 and the Madras high court pronounced the verdict in March 2018. Broadcasters then went to Supreme Court, which upheld the order later on and the NTO 1.0 finally came into effect from mid 2019. NTO 1.0 implementation was NOT deferred to March 2020, NTO 1.0 had come into effect in mid 2019 itself. After looking at the market response for almost one year, TRAI came up with the NTO 2.0 amendments in Jan 2020.

You are COMPLETELY confused with the timelines, and you don't know what you are saying. I can't help but pity the situation here.

I am not wrong anna rather u r getting confused and not understanding all the points properly

We all can understand who is the REAL CONFUSED one here, looking at the responses we are getting for both our posts.

 

[Vadirocks]

@dino29 Are You Saying Discount Cap Was There At 33% Under NTO 1.0???

 

[Siva]

@dino29 Are You Saying Discount Cap Was There At 33% Under NTO 1.0???

No, he is saying 35<33

 

[mmadhankumar]

No, he is saying 35<33

Waiting for his calculations.. it would be an amazing find today, which happens to be National Mathematics Day...

 

[Vadirocks]

No, he is saying 35<33

I Told You, It's My Mom-In-Law Birthday Today,

If I Get Late, I'm Gone
So Please End This ASAP,

@dino29 Just Say Yes O rNo For This Question,,,

"Discount Cap Was There At 33% Under NTO 1.0???"

 

[andrewkane14]

Waiting for his calculations.. it would be an amazing find today, which happens to be National Mathematics Day...

Earlier English exam now mathematical exam, next science exam?, I think this thread for online half-yearly examination