Discussion Should all SD channels adopt 16:9 ratio broadcast?

[satyajeet]

TV aspect ratio is set to "normal". So it is not stretched. It showing actual picture.

See.
I added 9x jalwa stretched as well as non-stretched.

 

[Bulgari]

See.
I added 9x jalwa stretched as well as non-stretched.

Bro the original source they have for these videos may be in 4:3. To fit their 16:9 canvas, they stretch it. This will make the video thin and black bars wider. This is only for some videos. Not entire channel feed.

 

[Bulgari]

I have many latest movies in 4:3. I will stretch one to 16:9 and post SS here.

 

[satyajeet]

Bro the original source they have for these videos may be in 4:3. To fit their 16:9 canvas, they stretch it. This will make the video thin and black bars wider. This is only for some videos. Not entire channel feed.

It is your wrong assumption that original video is in 4:3. This song is from 2013 movie. It must be either 16:9 or 21:9(cinematic ratio)

 

[satyajeet]

I have many latest movies in 4:3. I will stretch one to 16:9 and post SS here.

The song ss i have put is not in 4:3. Still stretched because broadcaster added black bars at top/botton to fit in 4:3 canvas.

 

[Bulgari]

It is your wrong assumption that original video is in 4:3. This song is from 2013 movie. It must be either 16:9 or 21:9(cinematic ratio)

They can be put in a 4:3 frame/canvas. In vhs and vcd days, Cinematic ratio movies are first put in 4:3 canvas and recorded on vhs/vcd

 

[satyajeet]

They can be put in a 4:3 frame/canvas. In vhs and vcd days, Cinematic ratio movies are first put in 4:3 canvas and recorded on vhs/vcd

Dont drag for sake of argument. Can't you see, movie is from 2013. U can see movie to prove that it is not in 4:3

 

[Bulgari]

The song ss i have put is not in 4:3. Still stretched because broadcaster added black bars at top/botton to fit in 4:3 canvas.

It's the other way. They have it in 4:3 canvas. Then stretch to fit 16:9 canvas.

I am out of home now. I will post ss when I get home.

 

[satyajeet]

It's the other way. They have it in 4:3 canvas. Then stretch to fit 16:9 canvas.

I am out of home now. I will post ss when I get home.

Keep dreaming. 2013 movie shot in 4:3 convas!!

 

[Bulgari]

Keep dreaming. 2013 movie shot in 4:3 convas!!

Not shot in 4:3. Shot in 21/9 and then transferred to 4:3 canvas. You will understand when I post ss