Tdsat dismisses Pune MSO plea against Ten Sports for digital signals

anilsk01

Contributor
Joined
25 Mar 2011
Messages
2,332
Reaction score
1,089
NEW DELHI: The Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal (Tdsat) has rejected a petition by the Pune-based
multi-system-operator Intermedia Cable Communication (ICC) against Ten Sports seeking directions that the sports channel must provide digital signals to it on a voluntary Cas basis.

After hearing the case, Tdsat chairman SP Sinha and Member PK Rastogi said the MSO cannot enforce MoU against Ten Sports since ICC themselves have not provided Subscriber Line Report (SLR). The tribunal also levied a cost of Rs 50,000 on the MSO.


It was also noted that since ICC chose not to divulge the subscriber base which it had with other sports channels, non-production of the documents could entail drawing of an adverse inference against it. The tribunal observed that it is highly improbable that ICC did not know its subscriber numbers/base.

This means Ten Sports can re-negotiate with ICC on the minimum subscriber base of 31,000. Furthermore, Ten Sports is not obliged to provide the digital signals akin to Cas in a non-Cas area.



Ten Sports had claimed that the broadcaster is obliged to supply signal to MSO on a non-discriminatory basis, but it does not necessarily mean that the MSO has a legal right to receive signals on an addressable system irrespective of the fact that other MSOs are not ready and willing to take supply of signals on a digital platform.

Furthermore, the Central Government has not declared Pune as a Cas area. Hence, Ten Sports is not bound to supply signals on a digital platform. Voluntary Cas has been connected by way of mutual agreement and not by way of compulsion.

On the other hand, the MSO had said the broadcaster was statutorily obliged to supply signals on a digital mode especially if it was willing to put in place the requisite equipment and also comply with the various terms and conditions. It was further argued that since the numbers have been agreed upon, the broadcasters can neither refuse any payment nor refuse to enter into an agreement.
 
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
DreamDTH.com Article Movie Plus directed by TDSAT to ensure some amount is available with Prasar Bharati as security DD Free Dish 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT refuses Discovery’s appeal for interim relief against TRAI’s 24th July NTO 2.0 directive DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT directs E-Digital to pay ZEEL Rs 8.32 crores within four weeks DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article ABCPL directed by TDSAT to pay GTPL 50% of balance dues for the resumption of signals DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT to dispose of Prasar Bharati plea against Movie Plus for non-payment of May dues later this month DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT adjourns Discovery petition impugning TRAI NTO 2.0 directive till Aug 24 DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT disposes of Andhra MSO appeal for MIB to pay damages DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article Antrix case against Tata Sky for recovery in TDSAT to be expedited after Supreme Court request DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article Movie Plus finding it difficult to furnish FBG to Prasar Bharati, no more relaxation from TDSAT DD Free Dish 0
DreamDTH.com Article Sadhna Media moves TDSAT against Antrix on Recovery DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article Superhit Broadcasting moves TDSAT against Prasar Bharati for forfeiture of Rs 1.5 Crore participation fee DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT extends interim arrangement between GTPL and 2 Andhra LCOs until 11th June DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT binds NXT Digital and Indiacast Media as per existing agreement without retention of old LCN Digital Cable TV 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT tells 2 Andhra LCOs to pay up GTPL arrears within 3 days or face disconnection Digital Cable TV 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT to gradually list pending matters whose hearing dates got dislocated DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT to take up urgent matters through Video Conferencing via Cisco WebEx DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article Swami Films Entertainment moves TDSAT against Prasar Bharati for interim relief DD Free Dish 10
DreamDTH.com Article Indiacast channels to enjoy old LCN placement on NXT Digital until further orders: TDSAT Digital Cable TV 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT restriction on functioning extended up to April 14 DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT rejects interim relief plea of Brahmaputra Teleproductions against disconnection from Axom Cable DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT to only hear urgent matters starting today in view of Covid-19 restrictions DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT restrains Zee Entertainment from disconnecting signal to Kal Cables DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
Akash Solanki Zee Move TDSAT to Recovere outstanding Independent tv General DTH News & Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT tells Independent TV to take steps to pay Indiacast Media dues or face execution of judgement and decree DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0
DreamDTH.com Article TDSAT disposes of VK Digital plea against Zee Entertainment DreamDTH Articles Discussions 0

Similar threads

Top Bottom
AdBlock Detected

We get it, advertisements are annoying!

Sure, ad-blocking software does a great job at blocking ads, but it also blocks useful features of our website. For the best site experience please disable your AdBlocker.

I've Disabled AdBlock